Last year for Joe’s birthday, I made him this cake. The layers were a tasty combination of:
- rainbow bit sponge
- vanilla cream cheese frosting
- sliced strawberries
- cheesecake {no crust} with strawberry preserve swirl
- vanilla cream cheese frosting
- sliced strawberries
- rainbow bit sponge
- strawberry preserve glaze on top of cake
So this year, I had to think of something different for him. The sweets that I’ve always known he loves are cheesecake, stale candy (don’t ask, it’s weird, right?), and peanut butter cups. One thing I also know he doesn’t love is fondant. I’m okay with that, because a lot of people don’t really like fondant. I will even peel most of it back when eating cake. (I’ll eat some of it though, especially if it’s a tasty brand like Virgin Ice Rolled Fondant! You can get it at the Bulk Barn for about $15 per 4 lb tub.)
I decided I was going to make him a peanut butter cup cake. (Not “cupcake”…) I didn’t shape it like a peanut butter cup, instead I allowed the cake to represent the flavours of the peanut butter cup. Here’s what I did for the cake:
- Sponge is rainbow bit (of course)
- Frosting in between layers is a mixture of vanilla and about 3 tbsp natural creamy peanut butter.
- Frosting on outside of cake is milk chocolate.
- Side of cake is decorated/coated with cut up Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups.
- Top of cake is decorated with “blobs” of vanilla-peanut butter frosting, and topped with more peanut butter cups.
Note: With the cake flavour, because I used a chocolate frosting with MANY peanut butter cups, and because the frosting on the inside of the cake was so rich, I wanted to make sure the cake had a light flavour to help balance it out. It’s a pretty heavy cake, even with the vanilla sponge being used instead of peanut butter or chocolate.
Simple as that! Now here’s a few pictures of this tasty mess!














